'Homes bid could wreck Bronte tourism'

Perves Abbas on the site Perves Abbas on the site

One of the world’s most famous literary societies has warned that plans for up to 320 homes on greenfield land in Bronte country could undermine the area’s heritage tourism.

Bradford businessman Perves Abbas has revealed plans to build 120 homes on grazing land at Weavers Hill, Haworth – and said that if the first phase was a success he would apply to build 200 more houses.

However, Christine Went, heritage and conservation officer for the Bronte Society, which draws its membership from across the world, said the development would be “disturbingly close” to the moorland which inspired the Bronte sisters.

It is next to a lane to Oxenhope known as “Charlotte’s Path” after Jane Eyre author Charlotte Bronte and is where she and her future husband, Arthur Bell Nicholls, held clandestine meetings before they were married.

In a posting on the Bronte Blog website, Mrs Went said: “Large numbers of new houses in this part of the village would have an extremely detrimental effect on its setting and would bring inappropriate development disturbingly close to the moorland fringes.

“The local economy is founded on heritage tourism. Anything which may undermine that economy must be examined closely and, if necessary, strongly rejected.”

She said the development was one field away from Dimples Lane, the boundary with Haworth’s famous moorland. “It is way too close,” said Mrs Went. “The last thing people visiting come to see is new houses.”

Mr Abbas said he would be submitting an application for the first phase of 120 homes to planners at Bradford Council soon.

He said that, if permission is agreed, his company would provide £500,000 towards schools, recreation areas and infrastructure in the area, as well as providing affordable homes.

Mr Abbas said any new houses would be “sensitive”.

He said: “We have already taken into consideration how it should look. There are already houses on Weavers Hill and this will complement those houses.”

In 2008 Mr Abbas was behind a plan for a 65-bed hotel and apartments on the same site but that met with opposition.

The plans have also sparked concern from villagers, Haworth, Cross Roads and Stanbury Parish Council, and Bradford Council’s Worth Valley councillors.

A Twitter account – @SaveHaworth – has also been set up to rally opposition.

Comments(8)

Mixter says...
5:51pm Sun 21 Oct 12

How many schools can you fund for half a million. Forgetting for the moment the recreation and impact on infrastructure?

But, bearing this in mind this blokes human rights to make huge profits, and bradford councils additional rates they will claw in - whats a bit of historical heritage in comparison.

And, for Affordable Housing - read 'Problem Tenants'. There goes the neighbourhood before a sod is lifted!

Behind_the_8-Ball says...
1:10pm Tue 23 Oct 12

"And, for Affordable Housing - read 'Problem Tenants'. There goes the neighbourhood before a sod is lifted!"

You know, not everyone on a low income is a socially undesirable thug in a hooded top and trackies, who never pays a bill and lowers the local house prices just by continuing to draw breath. It seems to me that the only thing we actually have before a "Sod is lifted"... is a display of narrow-minded judgmental stereotyping. What about those young people from the area who cannot afford to get a home in their own village due to hugely overinflated house prices? Wouldn't they benefit? There's a definite whiff of NIMBY around here.

teddygoray says...
7:38pm Wed 24 Oct 12

We should be greatful mr abbas is wanting to invest in Haworth and is pumping in of interest from people wanting to move to a nice quiet area.

I cant understand why some people of Haworth are so backward and using this excellent venture to have a moan!

Ive heard the bronte museam is for sale and isnt getting enough visitors and they are struggling with footfall, so is the rest of Haworth as i personally visit it on a sunday and it was pretty quiet!

cronk stanley says...
9:19pm Wed 24 Oct 12

Not a case of nimby, it is a case of profit for the builder.

Take the Worth Valley railway for example, in a short while all you will see on your ride will be houses on each side of the line, and it is happening,.Main Street will be enshrouded in new builds,.all nice little boxes with postage stamp gardens, the tourists will come in their thousands I'm sure

Behind_the_8-Ball says...
10:24am Thu 25 Oct 12

Actually I don't take exception to the opinion that certain builders in the area seem intent on turning the worth valley into one large housing estate... that's a valid point; I just wanted to point out that lumping everyone who would benefit from Affordable Housing under the banner of "Problem Tenants" is wrong. There are many hard working, decent people who, due to circumstances, are on low incomes... I know I am. Yet I pay my bills, contribute to society and try to live a quiet life. I don't think I'd deserve to have that rather blinkered judgement leveled at me, simply because I'd be one of the people interested in affordable housing.

Mixter says...
1:40pm Thu 25 Oct 12

Behind_the_8-Ball wrote:
"And, for Affordable Housing - read 'Problem Tenants'. There goes the neighbourhood before a sod is lifted!"

You know, not everyone on a low income is a socially undesirable thug in a hooded top and trackies, who never pays a bill and lowers the local house prices just by continuing to draw breath. It seems to me that the only thing we actually have before a "Sod is lifted"... is a display of narrow-minded judgmental stereotyping. What about those young people from the area who cannot afford to get a home in their own village due to hugely overinflated house prices? Wouldn't they benefit? There's a definite whiff of NIMBY around here.
While i fully agree not all AH tenants are undesirable, you dont need an estate-full to cause misery. Id put it to you that YOU wouldnt fancy living next door to the above - like any decent home-owner.tenant. Id also welcome these houses to be specifically for Haworth folk - even the less desirable. But its usually the sort that the Council etc can do nowt with so foist them on decent neighbourhoods. I dont knw a singke AH estate in the Kly area that doesnt have problems because of a handful of wasters.

And as for NIMBYing , i dont live anywhere near Haworth - i just care about areas being ruined. No stereotyping on your part there eh!

Behind_the_8-Ball says...
3:20pm Thu 25 Oct 12

I'm not stereotyping... the whiff of NIMBY refers to a type of comment... not to the poster. You're free to put anything you like to ME, seeing as I respect your right to any opinion free speech allows... however I may not fit whatever pigeonhole you have chosen for me...

jimmy k says...
9:11pm Thu 25 Oct 12

when the tourists do some to main street all the shops are usually closed thats why they stopped coming,typical village mentality,you can come and spend your money here but you'd better not want to live here. they want their cake and eat it.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree